Swilley law Firm

Importance of Drafting a Strong Florence Car Accident Demand Letter

December 10, 2025
At Swilley Law Firm, we understand that navigating the legal system can be overwhelming and stressful. That's why having the right advocate by your side can make all the difference. No matter the complexity of your situation, you don't have to face it alone. Get in touch with us today.
Free Consultation
100% Secure and Confidential

client testimonials

Hear from our satisfied clients

Car accident victims can receive compensation when another motorist strikes them, but negotiating a settlement is complicated. A central part of the negotiation process is the car accident demand letter. This letter contains critical information about the accident and your injuries. You should also include the amount you are willing to settle for. Call Swilley Law Firm, LLC, for help with your car accident claim. A Florence car accident lawyer can draft your letter and handle negotiations from start to finish.

What is the Purpose of a Car Accident Demand Letter?

This letter relays critical information about the accident from your point of view to the driver who hit you. This letter should include:

  • A summary of how the accident happened. Provide a narrative of what you remembered about the accident. For example, you might have been idling at a red light when a car crashed into you from behind.
  • Description of your injuries. You should identify all injuries, including the date of diagnosis.
  • Details regarding the cost of medical treatment and lost income. You need to provide details about your economic losses, since they make up a large part of any settlement.
  • Information about the pain and distress you feel. Accidents do more than cost motorists money. You can also struggle with painful bodily injuries, as well as anxiety and other mental distress.

The letter all builds up to the demand: the amount of money you are willing to settle your case for. If you don’t agree to a settlement, then you have the right to file a personal injury lawsuit.

A demand letter for car accident injuries starts the negotiation process. The other side will read the letter and determine what action to take.

Is a Demand Letter Necessary?

Yes. You could certainly negotiate orally and never write anything down. Your lawyer could pick up the phone and have a long conversation with the defendant’s lawyer. But a written letter documents everything. You can always refer to the letter if there is a dispute about what you said regarding the accident or your injuries.

Weak Demand Letters Hurt Your Florence Car Accident Case

Any car accident victim should hire a lawyer to draft a settlement demand letter for car accident injuries. You want to avoid the following:

  • Poorly written letters. These are hard to read, and you’ll lose your reader’s interest. A letter riddled with typos and grammatical errors suggests you might have a poor grasp of the facts.
  • Not enough detail. The reader is usually the insurance carrier for the driver who hit you. The letter should give them a strong sense that their insured was to blame for the crash and that you have significant injuries.
  • Too much detail. There is no reason to disclose everything in the first letter. For example, we might only gesture toward your pain and suffering but save more details for a subsequent letter.
  • Inaccurate information. You want to be 100% accurate in the letter. Any misstatements might be used against you later. Half-truths also destroy trust in the reader.
  • Exaggerations. You don’t want to make exaggerations that reduce your credibility. For example, it’s an exaggeration to say you haven’t slept for a month.

Work with an attorney to ensure your letter is strong. Our Florence car accident lawyer is happy to help. You want to send a demand letter before the statute of limitations expires, which is three years in many cases. (South Carolina Code § 15-3-530(5).)

The Key to a Car Accident Demand Letter: Your Proposed Compensation

A well-written demand letter is essential. But the key part is how much you propose to settle your claim for. The letter contains a number and a sentence, such as, “I propose to settle this claim for $100,000.”

This letter starts the negotiation process. We fully expect the other side to reject our proposal and make a counteroffer. For this reason, you need to give considerable thought to the number you include in the first demand letter.

We usually aim high, which gives our firm some room to come down. Let’s say our analysis shows that $50,000 is a fair amount of compensation for your injuries. We wouldn’t include that number in the initial demand letter, because then there is nowhere to go.

Instead, we might start high, around $75,000. That gives us room to come down without going too low. We always expect the other side to negotiate. And if they don’t? Then you might receive a larger settlement than usual.

How Negotiations Play Out

Once the defendant reads our demand letter, they usually write one of their own. Typically, they reject our proposed settlement and make a counteroffer. This counter is usually too low, so we need to draft a follow-up letter.

All subsequent communications should be just as solidly written as the initial demand letter for your car accident case. An experienced lawyer knows what points to make, such as emphasizing the pain you feel.

Defendants refuse to immediately settle for a couple of reasons. Usually, the defendant disagrees about fault. They might claim you were partially to blame for the collision, so they want to offer less compensation. South Carolina law states that your compensation is reduced in proportion to your share of fault. If you are 40% to blame, they will offer 40% less than if you were totally blameless.

The defendant might also disagree regarding the severity of your injuries, especially the pain. We can counter by providing more detail about how your injuries have disrupted your daily life. A vivid couple of paragraphs can convince them that your injuries warrant the compensation requested.

Speak with a Florence Car Accident Lawyer Today

Our experienced attorneys at Swilley Law Firm have handled many car accident cases in the 29501 zip code and nearby areas. You deserve the maximum compensation possible, and we can handle your settlement demand letter for your car accident case. In a free consultation, we can delve into greater detail about what happened and your injuries. We will draft an air-tight demand letter that explains clearly why you deserve a fair settlement. Call us to schedule a free, no-obligation consultation with our legal team.

Have any questions?

Our experienced team is dedicated to guiding you through the legal process and fighting for the justice you deserve
How much time do I have to file a personal injury lawsuit?

You have three years to file a personal injury lawsuit in South Carolina. A claim against the government must be started in two years. You don’t have to complete the case in that timeframe. You can meet the deadline by just one day and still receive your compensation. However, it’s always best to talk to a lawyer as soon as possible.

What is my personal injury case worth?

A personal injury case may seek compensation for economic loss, like medical bills, and personal loss, like pain and suffering. There are many types of losses that a person may have with a personal injury. These losses can be claimed as compensation. What your personal injury case is worth depends on several factors – the losses you have, how fault is assigned, and sources of compensation.

What is the difference between a felony and a misdemeanor?

Felonies are usually more serious offenses than misdemeanors. But each offense has its own maximum incarceration and other penalties.

Generally, felonies carry longer potential jail time than misdemeanors. In addition, felonies may result in the loss of rights, such as firearm possession and voting rights, that are not lost with misdemeanors.

How does the criminal defense process work in SC?

The criminal defense process begins when a person is charged with a crime. The person may be arrested, informed of the charges, or summoned to court. At the first hearing, the person pleads guilty or not guilty. The court may impose conditions on the bond.

More serious offenses begin with a preliminary hearing. There may also be a pre-trial conference and motion hearings, and the parties may discuss a plea bargain.

Available 24/7 • 100% Secure and Confidential

"*" indicates required fields